How Do You Balance Friendly Relationships With Your Team Members With Your Leading Role?
Read More
How Do You Balance Friendly Relationships with Your Team Members with Your Leading Role?
Sometimes these two roles can be in conflict and can influence work results and team spirit.
For example, have you ever been in a situation where you were in good terms with a team member and the relationship was easy, but you realized that you needed to tell them something about their work that might upset them and harm the relationship?
Maybe you sometimes overlooked certain things just to maintain the relationship as it is, only to later notice that those issues were repeated and that it was absolutely necessary to address them.
Or have you ever been in situations where things were not done on time because you spent too much time discussing personal matters or topics unrelated directly to the tasks you should have discussed?
And have you often been in situations where you were so focused on the team’s goals and planned everything with them, but you didn’t take the time to see how they are, whether they need support, if they face challenges, or what their morale state is?
They might have thought that you only care about achieving the goals and not about them. This could have decrease their engagement and motivation as well.
Let’s look at some ways in which you can balance these two roles:
Maintain work standards consistently, without making exceptions. Once team members understand what is required of them and that you’ll not allow or accept deviations, they will take the standards seriously. If you sometimes address a certain issue and sometimes you don’t, they may think that is not important to you, that you favour certain people, or that they can influence you due to your friendship with them. None of these scenarios will earn their respect or deliver the results you want.
When personal discussions tend to be too long, redirect them to the work tasks that need to be accomplished.
Relationships are built in the working process too – when members have the leader’s trust, when they receive support if they need it, when they can develop in the directions they want, when they receive appreciation for their work, when they feel safe to speak openly without the fear of losing something if they are honest.
One way to show that you care about your team members is to create a safe space for them. Resolve tensions, conflicts or disagreements within the team, and check their morale from time to time, as these issues can consume a lot of their energy and attention.
If team members are not united, if they sabotage each other, or if they don’t believe they can accomplish certain tasks, they won’t perform well, no matter how good the plans you made with them are.
Create opportunities for informal discussions as intentionally as you create opportunities for formal discussions. For example, provide recreational or lunch spaces where you can interact in a more relaxed way with team members, and where they can interact with each other as well. You can also bring them together for a festive lunch every now and then, or at team building events.
Friendly Relationships with Team Members Fall Under the Umbrella of Leader's Consideration Behaviour
According to early studies on leaders’ behaviour – Ohio State Leadership Studies – a leader has two major functions or roles:
- Consideration (People orientated) – The extent in which the leader is approachable and shows care for team members. Such leaders are seen as friendly, impartial and protective with their team members.
- Structuring (Task orientated) – The extent to which the leader focuses on achieving the team’s goals. They emphasize standard procedures, work scheduling, and the distribution of people across activities.
Some leaders may have better skills in structuring team activities than in building a cohesive team, while others may be great at both.
How would you assess your own skills in these two roles?
These two functions have a major impact on the employee satisfaction and performance.
In some situations, consideration is more appreciated, bringing satisfaction and increasing performance, while in other situations the structuring function is more important and increases employees’ satisfaction and performance.
WHEN employees are under deadlines pressure, don’t know how to do their tasks, or face external threats, they appreciate the structuring function more.
WHEN the work goals and methods are very clear, employees appreciate the consideration function more. They don’t need guidelines or indications because they already know what to do. In fact, they can become dissatisfied when they receive guidelines if they don’t need them.
WHEN the activities employees perform gives them intrinsic motivation, the needs for structuring and consideration are not so important.
For example, if a programmer likes the project on which he’s working on, he doesn’t need constant attention or encouragements from his leader to make progress. Even if he doesn’t always know how to do something, he is motivated enough to look for answers and solutions.
Among the theories that have studied when these two behaviours are appropriate is the Situational Leadership Model, developed by Paul Hersey and Kenneth Blanchard.
The premise of this theory is that different situations require different ways of leading.
In this leadership model, there are four types of leadership styles:
- Directing
- Coaching
- Supporting
- Delegating
These styles are generated by different combination of two main behaviours of the leader:
1.
Directive behaviour (similar with structuring) – consists of setting the objectives, the evaluation methods, the time limits, defining the roles, and establishing the ways in which the set objectives can be achieved. In this case, communication is one-way, from the leader to the employees.
2.
Supportive behaviour (similar to consideration) – the leader supports the team members in adapting to the situations in which they find themselves and integrating themselves into the working group, including in the relationship with him or her.
S1
Directing leadership style – the leader has a high directive behaviour and low supportive behaviour. The leader sets the objectives, the evaluation methods, the deadlines, defines the roles, and demonstrates the ways in which the objectives can be achieved. Communication is one-way.
S2
Coaching style – the leader is both highly directive and highly supportive. Communication aims both to achieve the objectives and to satisfy the socio-emotional needs of the employees.
S3
Supporting style – the leader is highly supportive and low directive. The tendency is to rely an implicit communication, show empathy, provide feedback, and focus on listening and professional development of the team members.
S4
Delegating style – the leader is low supportive and low directive. The leader gives to the employees the responsibility for accomplishing the tasks and for developing a positive environment as well. Communication is limited both quantitatively and qualitatively.
These leadership styles can be applied at the same time to different employees, depending on their particular development levels.
D1
The enthusiastic beginner – low competence & high commitment. The most adequate leadership style is S1, the directing style.
The employee can be a young new employee who is happy to work in the company, satisfied with his or her job responsibilities, and eager to do well, but because they don’t have much experience and face many situations that are new to them, they fail to get good results.
With a directing style, the leader can help employees achieve better results by telling them what to do and how to carry out their activities. Thus, employees can gain the necessary knowledge and practice to perform well. This will also avoid wasting time and efforts.
D2
The disillusioned learner – some competence & low commitment. The most adequate style is S2, the coaching style.
After the enthusiastic phase, if the employee doesn’t receive the help they need, they may begin to feel disappointed by their poor results, and their commitment level will go down. They need to be guided to know what to do and how to do it, and they also need emotional support to gain confidence that they are capable to accomplishing their tasks.
D3
The capable but cautious performer – high competence & variable commitment. The supportive style, S3, is adequate.
This can be the case of an employee who is experienced and has the necessary competence, but because they are in a new situation, or have new tasks, they act cautiously to avoid making any mistakes. They need encouragement from their leader to gain confidence. They may delay some things to double-check them, hesitate to move to the next step until they know exactly what will happen, etc.
Or it may be the situation of an employee who had a recent failure and is afraid of repeating it, even though they had numerous successes before. That failure could have been caused by external causes beyond their control or by factors that are no longer a problem.
D4
The self-reliant achiever – high competence & high commitment. The most adequate leadership style is the delegating one, S4.
In this phase, the employee has high competence and high commitment, so there is no need for the leader to be involved in their work. They know what to do, how to do it, and by when. Any unnecessary involvement will just bother them.
Do you adapt your leadership style to the development level of each employee?
Let me know if this blog post is helpful for you at: daniela.tancau@improvework.ro
Want to have more resources and tools to leverage your leadership skills?
The ONLINE PROGRAM:
How To Motivate Your Employees So They Care For Your Business And Help You Grow It
HAS YOUR BACK. It covers that along with other key aspects of employees’ motivation.
